First of all, I’m approaching this blog with much trepidation. I’m frightened by the difficulty in stripping New Orleans down to a laundry list of identifiable characteristics that are mirrored in the two equally complex and extreme characters we have been studying. Nevertheless, I press on.
And so we have it. John Kennedy Toole’s Ignatius Riley vs. Walker Percy’s Binx Bolling. Two equally ridiculous characters facing off from separate corners of their twisted, convoluted outlooks on life, dueling for the title of New Orleans. On one side, Ignatius’ brilliant but irrational nature fuels his feistiness that could definitely pack a punch, even if it comes sideways and unexpectedly. On the other, Binx’s quip and lack of concern for consequences gives his words an unforgiving bite that leaves a penetrating mark. It’s a fight for the death as each character flaunts its qualities in hopes of becoming the best at encompassing the true spirit of New Orleans.
Although I would LOVE to actually see this fight, I’ll go ahead and put my money on Ignatius for this round. It is a tough match, because Binx’s “I do what I want” nature is definitely seen in New Orleans culture. However, it is Ignatius’ ludicrous manner of carrying himself through the city that gives him the title. His nonchalance and transparent desires lead to a lifestyle that denies itself nothing… whether that be unlimited lucky dogs or wine cakes. On a broader sense, New Orleans is always granting wishes for its citizens, even if that may be something deemed inappropriate elsewhere (as evident by Bourbon Street going strong on Monday night). Not only does it allow these obscenities to occur, but it boasts about them in broad daylight, unafraid of what others may think. Much like Ignatius, the city parades itself for all to see, priding itself on its less than perfect reputation. But it is THIS trait that makes the city so intriguing. It has no fear of others, but is eager to invite outsiders in and let them stay awhile (much like Macon Fry the Garden Guy).
Honestly, I think that’s the reason why I love New Orleans so much.
Sarah,
ReplyDeleteA heavy-weight bout between Ignatius and Binx--a perfect way to frame the question and duke it out.
You write:
"Much like Ignatius, the city parades itself for all to see, priding itself on its less than perfect reputation. But it is THIS trait that makes the city so intriguing. It has no fear of others, but is eager to invite outsiders in and let them stay awhile."
What do we gain when we openly display our "less than perfect reputation"--complete freedom from hypocrisy?
This is a dinner table question, for sure.
DB
Freedom from hypocrisy--or fraudulent respite from self-improvement?
ReplyDelete